As a lifelong Dolfan, my journey with this team runs deep. I grew up celebrating the legacy of the undefeated 1972 Miami Dolphins — a team that will forever hold a sacred place in NFL history. I watched with pride during the era of Super Bowl appearances and waited patiently for the day we would return to that glory.
But as the years passed, that pride turned into something harder to hold onto.
There have been seasons when it was genuinely embarrassing to admit I was a Dolphins fan. And yet, we always found comfort in the one thing no other team could claim — the perfect season. The 17-0 record has become more than a badge of honor; it has become the thing we cling to while everything else about the team seems lost.
And now, I believe it’s time.
It’s time to bring that era to a dignified close — not just the season, but the identity itself. The Miami Dolphins name and brand, as it stands today, no longer represents excellence, unity, or hope. It represents years of mismanagement, disappointment, and missed opportunities. It’s time to start over. A fresh identity, a new brand, and a rebirth of what this franchise could be — all while honoring the greatness of that undefeated team, who should be celebrated as legends, not as shields from the present.
This isn’t just about the logo or the name — it’s about the foundation. The culture. The leadership.
Let’s be honest: The invisible hands shaping this team — from the top of the front office to the product on the field — have failed us repeatedly. The General Manager position has been a revolving door of poor decision-making and short-sighted planning. Remember the Bill Parcells era? Another lost opportunity. We need a GM who can truly build a championship contender, not just flash potential for a season or two.
To Coach Mike McDaniel — I respect your innovation and leadership, but it’s time. This team needs a fresh voice, someone who brings both accountability and toughness. And while it’s not about race, it is about representation and opportunity. The NFL has long needed more qualified Black head coaches, and the Dolphins have an opportunity to lead by example — not with tokenism, but with a real commitment to diversity and excellence.
And finally, the quarterback position. We’ve gone through countless names, countless promises. Tua Tagovailoa, while showing sparks of brilliance, has not delivered when it counts. It’s not personal. It’s business. We’ve waited long enough for redemption since the Daunte Culpepper decision. It’s time to move forward with clarity and conviction.
So I say this with all the love and frustration of a lifelong fan:
Fire Chris Grier. Move on from Mike McDaniel. Say goodbye to Tua. And yes — retire the Dolphins name. Let that legacy stand untouched, celebrated for what it was, and not dragged down by what the team has become.
It’s been time. Now, let’s make it official.
Sincerely,
A Heartbroken but Hopeful Fan